Decisions Of the Appeals Board

The following decisions have been issued by the board members of the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board and are presented here for information only. All steps have been taken to ensure the validity of these files. However, the printed versions of the decisions remain the official documents. Description and summary information appearing on this page are for the convenience of the reader and NOT considered part of the decision. Decisions of administrative law judges are binding on the parties in the particular matter but do not have precedential value. Only decisions after reconsideration and denials of petitions for reconsideration, which are rendered by the three-member appeals board, have precedential value and may be cited.

Beginning with the cases issued in 2005, for your convenience, a notation of the safety order at issue in the case has been added under the title of the case. The date of issuance has also been added for those cases.

To view the full text of each decision, click on the docket number located to the right of the decision's date of issue.

Decisions After Reconsideration are currently available from 2016 through September 23, 2019.



Case Name Date Issued Docket Number
MICRODYN-NADIR US, INC. 09/23/2019 Inspection No. 1352895
LIBERTY MFG., INC. dba CONQUEST INDUSTRIES 08/28/2019 Inspection No. 1295850
NORROMMY, INC. dba LEE’S AUTO & MUFFLER 08/28/2019 Inspection No. 1094206
PROCESS COOLING INTERNATIONAL INC. 08/23/2019 Inspection No. 1232555
OWENS CORNING ROOFING & ASPHALT LLC 08/23/2019 Inspection No. 1063574
SUPER KING MARKETS 08/23/2019 Inspection No. 1176203
ON THE THIRTY, INC. 08/15/2019 Inspection No. 1345451
CINTAS CORPORATION 07/29/2019 Inspection No. 1355423
ROBERT L. HORVATH, INC. dba CLAYBORN LAB 07/17/2019 Inspection No. 1333532
MARDAV MANUFACTURING, INC. dba SELECT SLEEP MATTRESS 07/17/2019 Inspection No. 1310206
AC TRANSIT 07/12/2019 Inspection No. 310060629 (Amended)
SHIMMICK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC 07/05/2019 Inspection No. 1059365
JOSEPH CROWN CONSTRUCTION, INC. 07/05/2019 Inspection No. 1351545
REAL TIME STAFFING SERVICES, LLC dba SELECT STAFFING 07/02/2019 Inspection No. 1342020
SOUTHLAND INDUSTRIES 07/01/2019 Inspection No. 1137088
ANITA’S MEXICAN FOODS CORP. 06/27/2019 Inspection No. 1319149
PEARL CROP, INC. 06/27/2019 Inspection No. 1269612
P & R PAPER SUPPLY COMPANY INC. 06/21/2019 Inspection No. 1336043
JOSEPH PERALTA 06/17/2019 Inspection No. 1071914 (Amended)
ALPHA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INCORPORATED 05/29/2019 Inspection No. 1180499
CALIFORNIA STRUCTURAL CONCEPTS INC. dba CALIFORNIA STRUCTURAL CONCEPTS 05/29/2019 Inspection No. 1205214
KPRS CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. 05/29/2019 Inspection No. 1192145
NATIONAL RETAIL TRANSPORTATION, INC. dba NRT INC. 05/28/2019 Inspection No. 1200875
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 05/28/2019 Inspection No. 1116529
WESTERN DIGITAL CORPORATION 05/16/2019 Inspection No. 1200858
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSTRUCTION GROUP 05/16/2019 Inspection No. 1129260
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON 05/15/2019 Inspection No. 1116095
H.B. REDWOOD MOULDING MANUFACTURING CO. 05/09/2019 Inspection No. 1266860
J.M. EQUIPMENT COMPANY, INC. 05/09/2019 Inspection No. 1155353
OPPORTUNITY STAFFING, INC. 05/09/2019 Inspection No. 1307854
SILICONSAGE CONSTRUCTION, INC. 05/09/2019 Inspection No. 1188395
CITY VENTURES CONSTRUCTION, INC. 05/02/2019 Inspection No. 1307598
PERFORMANCE TEAM FREIGHT SYSTEMS 05/01/2019 Inspection No. 1183505
WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC. 04/26/2019 Inspection No. 1180192
ROBERT CHAMPAGNE LANDSCAPE 04/25/2019 Inspection No. 1291708
JOHNSON UNITED INC dba UNITED SIGN SYSTEMS 04/22/2019 Inspection No. 1325955
DURHAM CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. 04/22/2019 Inspection No. 1316483
HERBERT ALLEN KELLY dba KELLY ROOFING COMPANY 04/12/2019 Inspection No. 1221889
ROBINSON MFG., INC. 04/02/2019 Inspection No. 1169633
WARREN MANH YOUNG 04/02/2019 Inspection No. 1308933
AC TRANSIT 03/28/2019 Inspection No. 310060629
BUZEK CONSTRUCTION, INC. 03/27/2019 Inspection No. 1203246
BIGGE GROUP DBA BIGGE CRANE & RIGGING CO. 03/15/2019 Inspection No. 317230191
SUNVIEW VINEYARDS OF CALIFORNIA, INC. 03/15/2019 Inspection No. 1193994
TIMBERWORKS CONSTRUCTION, INC. 03/12/2019 Inspection No. 1097751
CLAYCO, INC. 03/06/2019 Inspection No. 1312270
MS INTERNATIONAL, INC. dba MSI 03/05/2019 Inspection No. 1311568
VALLARTA SUPERMARKETS 02/20/2019 Inspection No. 1317404
JFJ PIPELINE, INC. 02/14/2019 Inspection No. 1094067
RUI LIANG dba TE CONSTRUCTION AND ELECTRIC INC. 02/14/2019 Inspection No. 1312675
BAKER’S 4 INC. dba TAM’s BURGERS 02/08/2019 Inspection No. 1216971
TMC GENERAL CONSTRUCTION, INC. dba TMC CONSTRUCTION 01/28/2019 Inspection No. 1250102
NORM WILSON & SONS, INC. 01/25/2019 Inspection No. 1116151
KS INDUSTRIES, L.P. 01/10/2019 Inspection No. 1084531
AMERISK ENGINEERING CORP. 12/21/2018 Inspection No. 1129146
PAGE E. TAYLOR DBA N&N CONCESSIONS 12/03/2018 Inspection No. 1258337
PRATHER DRYWALL & PLASTERING, INC. 12/03/2018 Inspection No. 1192427
HEMINGTON LANDSCAPE SERVICES, INC. 11/20/2018 Inspection No. 1300729
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 11/15/2018 Inspection No. 1158285
BRAGG COMPANIES dba BRAGG CRANE SERVICE 11/02/2018 Inspection No. 1157108
FLEETWORKS, INC. 11/01/2018 Inspection No. 1292093
ACAPULCO POLISHING CORPORATION 10/31/2018 Inspection No. 1285466
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE, INC. dba UPS 10/31/2018 Inspection No. 1273411
PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE dba AT&T CALIFORNIA 10/15/2018 Inspection No. 1242967
FEDEX FREIGHT INC. 09/24/2018 Inspection No. 1099855
BLUE DIAMOND GROWERS 09/24/2018 Inspection No. 1040471
ESCONDIDO LANDSCAPE, INC. dba NATURE DESIGNS 09/21/2018 Inspection No. 1244251
MATT ESKANDER 09/10/2018 Inspection No. 1213456
KINGSBURG APPLE PACKERS INC. 09/06/2018 Inspection No. 1269041
SALVADOR NEFTALI CASTRO dba CASTRO TIRE & TRUCK WASH 09/04/2018 Inspection No. 1240208
SAN DIEGO GAS AND ELECTRIC 08/31/2018 Inspection No. 1082280
HLD FARM, INC 08/30/2018 Inspection No. 1237918
ALFONSO CORDOVA dba CORDOVA'S TIRE SHOP 08/28/2018 Inspection No. 1271927
RAMONA'S MEXICAN FOOD PRODUCTS, INC. 08/16/2018 Inspection No. 1216721
JEFF ABRAHAM dba ABRAHAM FARMS 07/30/2018 Inspection No. 1273354
A-1 ROOFING MANAGEMENT AND CONSTRUCTION, INC. dba A-ONE CONSTRUCTION 07/17/2018 Inspection No. 1252576
BULKLEY & ASSOCIATES, LLC 07/17/2018 Inspection No. 1052467
ROSE AUTO CLINIC & MUFFLER SERVICE 07/02/2018 Inspection No. 1092600
CONCEPT CONSULTANT, INC. 06/27/2018 Inspection No. 1275403
RONALD SAMUELSON 06/12/2018 Inspection No. 1177057
BEHRING-HOFMANN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE INC DBA BLACKHAWK MUSEUM 06/08/2018 Inspection No. 1115442
DONNER SUMMIT RESORT, LLC DBA DONNER SKI RANCH 06/08/2018 Inspection No. 1138045
UNVARNISHED, INC. 06/04/2018 Inspection No. 1223365
CECILIO MURRIETA dba EL TORO BRAVO TORILLERIA 05/29/2018 Inspection No. 1232113
CAMPAGNIA BISTRO 05/21/2018 Inspection No. 1282103
SUSAN BLAIS 05/17/2018 Inspection No. 1137343
RVGC PARTNERS, INC. dba ROYAL VISTA GOLD CLUB 04/09/2018 Inspection No. 1217938
LIGHTNING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, LLC. 03/15/2018 Inspection No. 1217801
GOLDEN PEDIC, INC. dba GOLDEN MATTRESS COMPANY 02/26/2018 Inspection No. 1117620
AT&T SERVICES, INC. 02/23/2018 Inspection No. 1184516
PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE COMPANY dba AT&T CALIFORNIA 02/23/2018 Inspection No. 1153217
SAFEWAY 02/22/2018 Inspection No. 1233790
SSA CONTAINERS, INC. 02/21/2018 Inspection No. 314758756
PENHALL COMPANY 02/20/2018 Inspection No. 1128788
DOO RITE PAINTING/WON LEE 02/14/2018 Inspection No. 1086123
MOUNTAIN F. ENTERPRISES 02/14/2018 Inspection No. 1113595
WALSH/SHEA CORRIDOR CONSTRUCTORS 02/09/2018 Inspection No. 1093606
GUADALUPE RAMOS LAWN & TREE SERVICE 01/31/2018 Inspection No. 1188067
BASSETT MASONRY 01/25/2018 Inspection No. 1080329
EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY COMPANY 01/25/2018 Inspection No. 1091462
HARBOR ORNAMENTAL, INC. 01/25/2018 Inspection No. 1243017
JENIN HOME FASHION 01/18/2018 Inspection No. 1107117
FEDEX FREIGHT INC 01/11/2018 Inspection No. 1099855
HECTOR ESPARZA CARRERA 01/11/2018 Inspection No. 1192162
IMPERIAL SUSHI 01/11/2018 Inspection No. 1219955
ANDREW TRINH 12/13/2017 Inspection No. 1108221
ARODZ MOTORSPORTS, LLC dba A1 TUNE AND LUBE 11/22/2017 Inspection No. 1087194
UPS GROUND FREIGHT INC dba UPS FREIGHT 11/22/2017 Inspection No. 1111325
ASHLEY FURNITURE INDUSTRIES, INC. 11/07/2017 Inspection No. 1016514
SAN DIEGO ROOFING 10/18/2017 Inspection No. 1193795
JUVENTINO A. VARGAS MASONRY 10/10/2017 Inspection No. 307394940
CROWN BUILDING MAINTENANCE CO. dba ABLE BUILDING MAINTENANCE CO 09/28/2017 Inspection No. 1158728
ELECTRICAL SYSTEMS AND INSTRUMENTATIONS INC. 09/22/2017 Inspection No. 316695469
HARRIS REBAR NORTHERN CALIFORNIA, INC. 09/22/2017 Inspection No. 1086663
PINNACLE TELECOMMUNICATIONS, INC. 09/22/2017 Inspection No. 317202901
SIERRA PACIFIC INDUSTRIES 09/22/2017 Inspection No. 317247278
VENTURA COASTAL, LLC 09/22/2017 Inspection No. 317808970
FOUR SEASONS TREE SERVICE 09/08/2017 Inspection No. 1127635
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE 09/06/2017 Inspection No. 315347864
M SQUARED CONSTRUCTION, INC. 08/31/2017 Inspection No. 1123437
BOB BRITT WELLS DBA ARROW ASPHALT PAVING 08/31/2017 Inspection No. 316522598
D S CARGO DBA CLOCK FREIGHT, INC. 08/15/2017 Inspection No. 1124296
HOME DEPOT USA, INC. dba HOME DEPOT #6683 08/15/2017 Inspection No. 1014901
PCC ROLLMET, INC. 08/15/2017 Inspection No. 1079636
RICHARD ALAN COLEMAN dba CAFE LUCCA 08/15/2017 Inspection No. 1173600
N B BAKER ELECTRIC, IND dba BAKER ELECTRIC SOLAR 08/10/2017 Inspection No. 1070836
PIZZA BEER AND WINGS LLC dba PIZZA, BEER, AND WINGS 08/10/2017 Inspection No. 1186280
TOOR MANAGEMENT, INC. 08/03/2017 Inspection No. 1178926
BARRETT BUSINESS SERVICES, INC. 08/03/2017 Inspection No. 1141194
EMPLOYBRIDGE HOLDING COMPANY dba SELECT STAFFING 08/03/2017 Inspection No. 1149249
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE, INC. 08/01/2017 Inspection No. 1116529
SHIMMICK-NICHOLSON CONSTRUCTION, A JOINT VENTURE 07/24/2017 Inspection No. 1021893
HOME DEPOT USA, INC. dba HOME DEPOT #6683 07/24/2017 Inspection No. 1014901
LIDESTRI FOODS, INC. 07/14/2017 Inspection No. 1187604
G FASHION INC. 07/06/2017 Inspection No. 1142005
EXXONMOBIL REFINING & SUPPLY COMPANY 07/05/2017 Inspection No. 1042440
A TEICHERT & SON, INC. DBA TEICHERT ROCK PRODUCTS 06/30/2017 Inspection No. 1047912
CALSTRIP STEEL CORPORATION 06/30/2017 Inspection No. 312668825
LION FARMS, LLC 06/30/2017 Inspection No. 1070258
LEAD RECLAMATION SERVICES 06/20/2017 Inspection No. 1120934
SOCAL ACCESSORY PRODUCTION 06/16/2017 Inspection No. 1171175
LINCO INDUSTRIES, INC. 06/05/2017 Inspection No. 1168551
TLK Steel Inc. 06/05/2017 Inspection No. 1190242
LEGACY SUPPLY CHAIN SEVICES INC 06/05/2017 Inspection No. 1151367
RNR CONSTRUCTION, INC. 05/26/2017 Inspection No. 1092600
JD2 INCORPORATED 05/26/2017 Inspection No. 1083954
KROEKER, INC. 05/22/2017 Inspection No. 1015555
ATKINSON CONSTRUCTION, LP 05/16/2017 Inspection No. 317386084
HOME DEPOT USA, INC. 05/16/2017 Inspection No. 1011071
DAVEY TREE SURGERY CO. 05/15/2017 Inspection No. 119920106
SYNERGY TREE TRIMMING, INC. 05/15/2017 Inspection No. 317253953
RAFIDAIN, INC. DBA GENIE CAR WASH & OIL CHANGE 05/12/2017 Inspection No. 1162918
TONE CONSTRUCTION INC. 05/12/2017 Inspection No. 1168886
Cesar Juan Leon dba CJL Construction 05/11/2017 Inspection No. 1158477
EMAD HANNA AYYOUB dba AZUSA AUTO SPA 05/11/2017 Inspection No. 1151700
THYSSENKRUPP ELEVATOR CORPORATION 04/18/2017 11-R2D1-2217 through 2219
ADA PRINTING & TRADING 04/13/2017 Inspection No. 1094782
BAUMAN LANDSCAPE AND CONSTRUCTION 04/13/2017 Inspection No. 1088283
BULLET CONSTRUCTION 04/13/2017 Inspection No. 1173664
SNF PALLETS, aka SAMUEL CORTEZ JR. dba S&S PALLETS 04/13/2017 Inspection No. 312746571
RELENTLESS METAL PRODUCTS 04/03/2017 Inspection No. 1169261
SHIMMICK CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. 03/30/2017 Inspection No. 1080515
GRIMMWAY ENTERPRISES, INC. 03/28/2017 Inspection No. 1001530
KINDNESS GENERAL CONTRACTORS, INC. 03/13/2017 Inspection No. 316981158
BARNARD IMPREGILO HEALY JV 03/10/2017 Inspection No. 317134021
MERRILL FARMS LLC 03/10/2017 Inspection No. 1180203
TORRES FARM LABOR CONTRACTOR 03/10/2017 Inspection No. 1158061
SHIMMICK FCC IMPREGILO JOINT VENTURE dba SFI, JV 03/10/2017 Inspection No. 1144056
BIGGE CRANE & RIGGING CO. 03/01/2017 Inspection No. 317351781
ROBERT A. BOTHMAN, INC. 03/01/2017 Inspection No. 317201556
C & C BROTHERS INC. dba LADERA CLEANERS INC. 02/27/2017 Inspection No. 1158694
GERDAU dba GERDAU REINFORCING STEEL 02/27/2017 Inspection No. 315832014
SUNFRESH USA, INC. 02/17/2017 Inspection No. 1186846
SAN JOAQUIN REFINING COMPANY 02/16/2017 Inspection No. 1162507
APELINC LANDSCAPE SERVICES 01/30/2017 Inspection No. 1185341
DYNAELECTRIC COMPANY dba WASATCH ELECTRIC 01/27/2017 Inspection No. 1083985
KEY ENERGY SERVICES, LLC 01/27/2017 Inspection No. 1004280
ETO DOORS CORPORATION,
NEW AGE DOORS, LLC.,
CONTEMPORARY DOORS, LLC.
01/26/2017 Inspection No. 1155124
WEBCOR CONSTRUCTION LP DBA WEBCOR BUILDERS 01/20/2017 Inspection No. 317176766
PNI CONSTRUCTION INC 01/05/2017 Inspection No. 1123971
FOUNDATION BUILDING MATERIALS LLC 12/23/2016 14-R1D2-3533 through 3535
OLDCASTLE PRECAST INC 12/22/2016 Inspection No. 1025083
HERRON CONSTRUCTION, INC. 12/22/2016 Inspection No. 1113956
BARRETT BUSINESS SERVICES, INC. 12/14/2016 12-R3D1-1204 through 1206
FEDEX FREIGHT, INC. 12/14/2016 12-R2D1-0144
DYNAMIC CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. 12/01/2016 14-R4D1-1471 and 1472
COAST WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC. 10/07/2016 11-R3D2-2385 and 2386
KEY ENERGY SERVICES, INC. 10/07/2016 15-R4D7-0255 and 0256
L & S CONSTRUCTION, INC. 10/07/2016 10-R3D1-1821 and 1822
NOLTE SHEET METAL, INC. 10/07/2016 14-R6D7-2777 through 2783
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE, INC 10/07/2016 16-R4D7-9109
MORROW MEADOWS CORPORATION 10/05/2016 12-R4D1-0717 through 0719
GATEWAY PACIFIC CONTRACTORS INC. 10/04/2016 10-R2D3-1502 through 1508
MASTER RECYCLING, INC. 09/30/2016 16-R6D2-1049 through 1051
MOORE'S PUMPKIN PATCH AND CHRISTMAS TREES 09/12/2016 15-R1D4-1504
CALIFORNIA CONSTRUCTION CONSULTANTS, INC. 09/08/2016 13-R4D1-2122 and 2123
KIMCO STAFFING SERVICES, INC. 08/26/2016 2015-R3D3-4594 and 4595
AVALON BAY COMMUNITIES. INC. 07/22/2016 15-R3D2-0751
EVERGREEN NURSERY 07/01/2016 15-R3D2-0083 and 0084
ST. JERIES ENTERPRISES, INC. dba EXPRESS AUTO SERVICES 06/30/2016 16-R6D5-9083
W. A. RASIC CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. 06/21/2016 13-R4D1-1422
UPS GROUND FREIGHT, INC. dba UPS FREIGHT 06/17/2016 16-R1D2-9043
BIG Q AUTO REPAIR, LLC 06/16/2016 16-R6D5-9060
ISM VUZEM USA, INC. 05/27/2016 16-R1D2-9047
PAN-PACIFIC PLUMBING CO. dba PAN-PACIFIC MECHANICAL 05/27/2016 14-R3D3-1020
SILVERADO CONTRACTORS, INC. 04/28/2016 14-R4D7-3044
TRUCK ACCESSORIES GROUP LLC 04/28/2016 16-R2D1-9019
MDB MANAGEMENT INC. 04/25/2016 14-R4D1-2373 and 2374
SOLARCITY CORPORATION 04/14/2016 14-R3D2-3707
SIERRA FOREST PRODUCTS 03/28/2016 09-R2D5-3979
BURTECH PIPELINE, INC. 03/28/2016 13-R3D2-0830 and 0831
CROP PRODUCTION SERVICES 03/28/2016 09-R6D4-4036 through 4038
EKEDAL CONCRETE, INC. 03/28/2016 13-R3D1-0131 through 0133
OC COMMUNICATIONS, INC. 03/28/2016 14-R2D2-0120, 0166 and 0340
LOUIS TANGALAKIS dba ELIAS CONSTRUCTION 03/24/2016 15-R4D1-9236
KNIGHT TRANSPORTATION PORT SERVICE, LLC 03/21/2016 15-R3D5-9225
GARY BOTHUN dba BOTHUN TURKEY FARM 03/15/2016 15-R4D2-0137
RAAM CONSTRUCTION, INC. 03/04/2016 15-R1D4-0155
MCM CONSTRUCTION, INC. 02/22/2016 13-R1D2-3851 through 3854
CALIFORNIA SECURITY & INVESTIGATIONS ACADEMY dba CSTA 02/22/2016 15-R2D1-9190
McCARTHY BUILDING CO., INC. 02/08/2016 12-R1D4-3458
ACTION METAL RECYCLING, INC. 01/29/2016 13-R2D2-1125 and 1126
EMPLOYER SOLUTIONS STAFFING GROUP II, LLC/FASTEMPS INC. 01/29/2016 2012-R3D6-3207 and 2012-R3D6-3208
WA RASIC CONSTRUCTION CO. INC. 01/29/2016 13-R3D1-2951 and 2952
McCARTHY BUILDING COMPANIES, INC. 01/11/2016 11-R4D2-1706 and 2046

February 2020

About OSHAB